Although income from bonuses is treated similarly to an employee’s salary, the method of taxation may differ. Bonuses classified as “supplemental wages” by the IRS may be taxed separately from standard salaries.
If the employer pays the bonus separately from the salary, a flat 22% withholding rate is applied for federal tax in most cases. However, if the total annual bonus amount exceeds $1 million, a higher rate of 37% applies to the amount exceeding $1 million.
In some cases, the employer may combine the bonus with the regular salary and make a single payment. In this case, the employee’s tax rate is calculated based on the total payment amount. This is called the “aggregate method,” and while it may initially appear to result in a higher tax deduction, it may not change the annual total tax burden.
In summary, bonuses are taxable; however, the rate and method of deduction vary depending on how the payment is made.
Why bonuses often appear to be taxed more heavily than regular income
Many employees realize that the net amount is lower than expected after receiving their bonus payment. The main reason for this is that bonuses are treated differently for tax purposes.
Since bonuses are considered a separate type of income from regular salary, employers may apply a higher withholding rate on these payments. In particular, when bonuses are paid as a separate check, the IRS’s fixed withholding rate of 22% applies. If the bonus amount exceeds $1 million, a 37% tax deduction is applied to the excess amount.
On the other hand, if the bonus is paid alongside regular wages, the employer may apply a higher tax deduction rate since the total income appears higher. This method can make the bonus appear more heavily taxed, especially for employees in higher wage brackets.
This tax difference stems more from the method of deduction during the year than from the final tax amount. Therefore, if too much tax has been paid, the employee may receive a tax refund at the end of the year.
What are the IRS methods for taxing bonuses
The IRS allows employers to use two basic withholding methods for bonus payments: flat rate and aggregate method. These methods directly affect the net bonus amount received by the employee.
The flat rate method may be preferred when the bonus is paid separately from regular wages. Under this method, a flat 22% federal income tax is withheld from the bonus amount. If the total bonus exceeds $1 million, a 37% rate is applied to the excess amount. This method is generally more predictable and simpler to administer.
The aggregate method is used when the bonus is combined with regular salary and paid as a single payment. In this method, the employer applies standard income tax withholding based on the employee’s W-4 form information for the entire payment. This may result in a high bonus received during the year appearing to be taxed at a higher rate.
Both methods are legal and IRS-approved. However, the employee’s total tax liability is finalized at the end of the year with the income tax return. Therefore, knowing which method is used is important for budget planning.
Are all types of bonuses taxed in the same way?
Although all bonuses are taxable, the taxation method varies depending on the type of bonus. Factors such as the type of bonus, payment method, and timing can affect the applicable tax rules.
Cash bonuses, such as year-end or signing bonuses, which are paid directly in cash, are classified as “supplemental wages” by the IRS and are taxed using the flat rate or aggregate method.
Signing and retention bonuses are given to hire or retain an employee. They are typically paid in a lump sum at the outset and are subject to the same withholding rules as other cash bonuses.
Stock-based bonuses (stock bonuses, RSUs) – Payments such as stock or stock options generally become taxable when the vesting date arrives. In such payments, tax is calculated based on the fair market value of the stock. Even if no cash payment is made, it is considered income.
Fringe benefits, such as concert tickets, gift cards, or special awards, may sometimes serve as substitutes for bonuses. Such payments may be tax-exempt within certain limits, but valuable or cash-equivalent gifts are generally reported as income and subject to taxation.
Although most bonuses are taxable, certain special circumstances may qualify for an exemption. Therefore, the type of bonus received should be clearly defined, and its tax implications should be evaluated by consulting a professional when necessary.
Are bonuses subject to Social Security, Medicare, and state taxes?
Bonus income is subject not only to federal income tax but also to various other mandatory deductions. These deductions include Social Security, Medicare, and state income taxes, which vary depending on the state in which the employee lives.
Under the Social Security tax, a 6.2% tax is levied on total earnings up to $176,100 annually as of 2025. No additional Social Security deductions are made once this limit is exceeded. If the bonus, combined with the salary, exceeds this limit, tax is only applied to the portion within the remaining limit.
Medicare tax applies to all income and is deducted at a rate of 1.45%. Additionally, an extra 0.9% “surtax” may apply to income exceeding $200,000 annually.
State taxes vary depending on your location. Most states treat bonuses as regular income and subject them to state income tax. However, some states either do not impose income tax or apply a special withholding rate for bonuses. For example, some states like Pennsylvania impose a flat rate, while others may use variable rates based on the employee’s income level.
In conclusion, bonuses are subject to a multi-layered tax system. In addition to federal income tax, they may be subject to Social Security, Medicare, and state-level deductions. Therefore, it is important to consider these factors before calculating the net amount you will receive.
Do bonus payments raise your tax bracket or affect deductions?
Bonuses can significantly increase your total annual income. This can move you into a higher tax bracket or cause you to lose certain tax benefits. However, this effect is often not as direct or permanent as people think.
The US income tax system is progressive. This means that only the portion of your income that exceeds a certain threshold is taxed at a higher rate, not your entire income. Therefore, even if receiving a bonus moves you into a higher bracket, you will only pay the higher tax rate on the portion that exceeds that bracket.
However, in some cases, bonuses can have indirect effects:
The threshold for eligibility for tax credits or deductions may be exceeded. For example, certain benefits like the Child Tax Credit may decrease or disappear entirely above certain income levels.
Strategies for claiming itemized deductions or standard deductions may change. If your income increases with a bonus, the tax impact of certain deductions may decrease.
Additional taxes, such as the Net Investment Income Tax, may apply once income exceeds certain thresholds. The bonus could cause you to exceed these thresholds.
The timing of the bonus is also important. A bonus received in December could increase your tax liability for that year, while delaying it until January would defer its impact to the following year.
Such effects may be more pronounced for individuals with other variable income sources during the year. Therefore, it may be wise to conduct a simple tax simulation or seek professional advice before receiving a large bonus.
No comments to show.